Understanding the Importance of a Cover Letter
In the competitive world of short story publishing, your manuscript is only half the battle. The cover letter serves as your introduction, your handshake, and your opportunity to make a memorable first impression. It’s not just a formality; it’s a crucial tool that can significantly increase your chances of getting your story read and potentially accepted. A well-crafted cover letter shows that you’re a professional writer who respects the publication and understands the submission process. It provides context for your story, highlighting its unique qualities and demonstrating your understanding of the target audience. Think of it as a carefully curated marketing pitch, designed to pique the editor’s interest and compel them to dive into your manuscript.
Why a Cover Letter Matters for Short Story Submissions
A cover letter is more than just a formality it’s your opportunity to distinguish yourself from the crowd. Editors often receive a large volume of submissions, and they need a way to quickly assess which stories are worth their time. A compelling cover letter immediately grabs their attention and provides them with crucial information about your story and your qualifications as a writer. This includes a brief summary of the story, relevant publication credits, and any other information that makes your submission stand out. It shows you have done your research on the publication, demonstrating your genuine interest in their specific content. A personalized cover letter will show you’re not simply mass-submitting your work.
Making a Strong First Impression

The initial impression you make can significantly influence the editor’s perception of your story. A well-written cover letter conveys professionalism, attention to detail, and a genuine enthusiasm for the publication. This first impression starts with the format of the letter. Ensure your contact information is easily accessible, and that the formatting is neat and professional. The tone should be polite, respectful, and enthusiastic, but not overly gushing. Avoid clichés and generic phrases; personalize the letter to the specific publication. A thoughtful, well-crafted cover letter is the first step in creating a positive impression that will encourage the editor to take your manuscript seriously.
Key Elements of a Winning Cover Letter
Several key elements contribute to an effective cover letter. First, include your contact information and the submission date. Then, personalize the letter to the specific publication and address the editor correctly. Briefly summarize your story, highlighting its strengths and unique aspects. Mention any relevant publications or awards, as well as any previous publications you may have. Maintain a professional tone throughout, paying close attention to formatting and presentation. Proofread carefully to eliminate any typos or grammatical errors. Adhering to these core elements will ensure your cover letter is well-received and leaves a lasting positive impression.
Your Contact Information
At the top of your cover letter, clearly state your contact information. This should include your full name, mailing address, email address, and phone number. Make sure this information is accurate and up-to-date. It’s also helpful to provide your website or online portfolio link if you have one, as this gives the editor an easy way to learn more about you and your work. The inclusion of your contact information is essential for the editor to reach you if they are interested in your story. Double-check all details to avoid any errors.
The Submission Date

Include the submission date to help the editor track when you sent your submission. While not always mandatory, it can be beneficial for record-keeping, particularly for the editor. Placing the date below your contact information sets the context for when the submission was sent. This can be formatted in a variety of ways, but consistency is key. Choose a format (e.g., Month Day, Year) and use it throughout all your cover letters. Some submission guidelines might specify how the date should be formatted, so always consult the publication’s specific requirements to ensure you are compliant.
Personalize the Cover Letter to the Publication
One of the most crucial elements of a winning cover letter is personalization. Tailor your letter to the specific publication to demonstrate that you’ve done your research. Refer to the publication’s name, and if possible, mention a specific issue, story, or author that you admire. This shows the editor that you understand the publication’s style, tone, and target audience. Avoid using generic language that could be used for any publication. Research the publication’s guidelines and adhere to any specific requirements they have for cover letters. A personalized approach makes a significant difference in capturing the editor’s attention and demonstrating your genuine interest in their publication.
Addressing the Editor Correctly
Addressing the editor correctly is another important detail. Take the time to find out the name of the editor or the specific person to whom you should address your cover letter. Using the editor’s name demonstrates respect and attention to detail. If the name isn’t readily available, search the publication’s website, social media, or contact the publication directly. Using “Dear Editor” is acceptable, but if you can find a name, it adds a personal touch. Avoid using generic greetings like “To Whom It May Concern,” which can make your submission feel impersonal. Get the editor’s name right and spell it correctly, this seemingly minor detail can make a positive impact.
Highlighting Your Story and Its Strengths

Your cover letter should briefly summarize your story and highlight its strengths. Keep the summary concise, typically no more than two or three sentences. Focus on the core elements of your story, its themes, and its unique selling points. What makes your story stand out? Is there a particular element that showcases your strengths as a writer? Briefly mention the genre, target audience (if applicable), and any notable aspects that you believe would appeal to the publication’s readership. The summary should be enticing, designed to pique the editor’s interest and encourage them to read your manuscript. Avoid giving away the entire plot; instead, focus on creating intrigue.
Crafting a Compelling Story Summary
When crafting your story summary, aim for clarity and brevity. Start with a sentence or two that provides a clear overview of the story’s premise. Then, highlight the central conflict, the protagonist’s goals, and any unique or compelling elements. Avoid spoilers. Focus on the core themes and the emotional impact of your story. Be sure that the summary is engaging, and accurately reflects the essence of your manuscript. A compelling summary will not only give the editor an understanding of the story but will also show the editor what kind of writer you are.
Mentioning Relevant Publications or Awards
If your story or any of your previous work has been recognized with awards or published in reputable publications, mention these details in your cover letter. This provides context and adds credibility to your submission. Mention any prizes your story has won in writing contests or any accolades it has received. This shows editors that your work has been vetted and recognized by others in the industry. If you have publications that are similar in style to the one you’re submitting to, mention them. This helps to establish that you have a strong grasp of the genre, and your work is a good fit for the publication’s content.
Showcasing Your Previous Publications (If Any)

Including any previous publications in your cover letter is a way to showcase your writing experience. Even if your publications are in different venues, listing them can show editors that you are a professional writer. List the names of the publications, and the dates of publication. Be selective: only mention those publications that are relevant to the submission or which demonstrate your ability as a writer. For writers with limited publications, any experience helps. For established writers, these can be a powerful endorsement of your talent and professional credibility.
Maintaining a Professional Tone
Throughout your cover letter, it’s important to maintain a professional tone. This includes using formal language, avoiding slang, and ensuring your writing is grammatically correct. Show respect for the editor and the publication. Avoid being overly familiar or casual. Keep your tone sincere and enthusiastic, but avoid hyperbole or exaggerated claims. Remember that this letter is a reflection of your professionalism, and it should project an image of a serious writer who takes their craft seriously. A well-written and professional cover letter demonstrates that you respect the editor’s time and the publication’s standards.
Formatting and Presentation Tips
Proper formatting and presentation are critical aspects of a winning cover letter. Adhere to the specific formatting guidelines requested by the publication. If no instructions are provided, use a standard business letter format. Use a clear, easy-to-read font like Times New Roman or Arial. Ensure your letter has proper margins, spacing, and alignment. Proofread carefully to avoid any formatting errors. Pay attention to the overall appearance of your cover letter, as this impacts the editor’s impression. A well-formatted cover letter is easier to read and projects professionalism.
Proofreading for Perfection

Proofreading is an essential step in the cover letter writing process. Before submitting your cover letter, carefully proofread it to eliminate typos, grammatical errors, and punctuation mistakes. Read your cover letter aloud to catch any awkward phrasing. Use spell-check and grammar-check tools, but don’t rely solely on them. Often, they can miss errors, such as subject-verb disagreements. Have someone else proofread your cover letter. Another pair of eyes can catch errors that you may have missed. A polished, error-free cover letter demonstrates your attention to detail and respect for the editor’s time.
Ensuring Proper Formatting
Proper formatting is essential for making your cover letter easy to read. Follow the publication’s specific formatting guidelines if available. If no specific guidelines are available, use a standard business letter format. Use a font size that is easy to read (e.g., 11- or 12-point font) such as Times New Roman or Arial. Ensure the letter has adequate margins (typically one inch on all sides). Use single spacing within paragraphs, and double spacing between paragraphs. Properly align your text (usually left-aligned). Formatting helps the editor focus on your writing and shows that you are serious about your craft.
Avoiding Common Mistakes
Avoid common mistakes that can undermine the effectiveness of your cover letter. These mistakes can range from using generic language to omitting important details. The most common mistakes include using generic language and clichés, adopting an overly casual tone, and making typos and grammatical errors. Be aware of these pitfalls to make sure your cover letter stands out for the right reasons.
Generic Language and Clichés

Avoid using generic phrases and clichés. Generic phrases, such as “I am writing to submit my story,” are overused and can make your cover letter feel impersonal. Instead, be specific and demonstrate a genuine interest in the publication. Avoid clichés, such as overly praising your story. Use language that is original, clear, and engaging. Demonstrating that you care and are paying attention will help the editor.
Overly Casual Tone
Maintain a professional tone. Avoid being overly casual or using slang or informal language. Your cover letter is a professional communication, and should reflect that. Even if the publication has a casual tone, your cover letter should remain respectful. Use proper grammar and punctuation, and write with clarity and precision. The appropriate tone will ensure you are taken seriously as a writer.
Typos and Grammatical Errors
Typos and grammatical errors can create a negative impression, signaling a lack of attention to detail. Proofread your cover letter carefully, and use a grammar and spell checker. Consider having someone else proofread your cover letter. Typos can be distracting and make the editor question your professionalism as a writer. A clean, error-free cover letter shows the editor that you value the submission process.
Tips for Different Submission Types
The approach to writing a cover letter can vary depending on the type of publication you’re submitting to. Different publications may have different preferences, so it is important to be aware of those. Literary magazines, anthologies, and online publications can have different guidelines, so read the guidelines carefully. Tailoring your cover letter to the specific publication is essential for increasing your chance of success. This includes understanding their unique style, audience, and preferences.
Submitting to Literary Magazines
When submitting to literary magazines, research the magazine’s style and the type of stories they publish. The tone is generally more formal, and there’s a strong emphasis on showcasing your writing talent. Highlight your story’s literary merits and discuss its themes and style. If you have published in other literary magazines, mention them, as this will build your credibility. Proofread your cover letter carefully, and ensure the submission is well-crafted to reflect the high standards of literary magazines.
Submitting to Anthologies
Anthologies often have specific themes or guidelines. Read the anthology’s submission guidelines carefully. Highlight how your story aligns with the anthology’s theme. Briefly explain why your story fits the theme, and what unique contributions it can make. If the anthology is published by a well-known publisher or features a notable editor, mentioning this will help to validate the submission. Show the editor that you have carefully considered the focus of the anthology, and that your story meets their specific requirements.
Submitting to Online Publications
Online publications may have different requirements than print magazines. Often, the submission process may be more streamlined and may require specific formatting, or may not need a cover letter at all. Always check the publication’s submission guidelines. If a cover letter is required, follow all instructions carefully. If you have published work online, or have experience with digital media, mention that in your cover letter. Demonstrate that your story is well-suited for an online platform.